A Returner's Magic Should Be Special

saiananthu
I mean guys at first i thought it was a manga where the character is op but he is not op .and not to spoil but everytime he cherishs his buddies and tries not to repeat the past.and he surpasses himself.tge story is very nice even though the concept about going to the shadow world is confusing
Reply · Dec 12, 2022

howliing
A story about fixing the past with experience and memories of the future..In my opinion this is very good,story is little slow paced but other than everything is fine...🍞
Reply · Nov 17, 2022

themedoguy
Dropped at 194, every known scanlation scan and even flamescan dropped it. THe series has become recycled cliche garbage with nothing knew , orginal or interesting. Author writing has all cliche and everything is predictable. Mc is an idiot who cant figure out shit to save his life without plot armor saving him. ALso orginal plot of shadow world is gone and its al labout good vs evil with the usual plot of evil always needs to escape and is never defeated until the end of the story crap. It was a good story at start but now its just grabage that iwoudnt recommend anyone waste time on.
Reply · Nov 16, 2022

tomodovodoo
A good story about a well set-up reincarnation plot, with good character and side-character development, just enough reincarnation power to not make it feel like he's OP, an enjoyable villain, and very cool action scenes. What more do you want from a reincarnation action manhwa?
Reply · Oct 03, 2022

cutelittlebaby
Totally not for me, it is very slow and how the eyes are drawn makes me not able to read it anymore.
Reply · Sep 05, 2022

nota1337
Meh, Not to my liking and it's probably mid asf.
Reply · Apr 12, 2022

goldenfury
This is definitely one of the best manhwas in my opinion and as far as for it to be a type of reincarnation manhwa this one is definitely a little different the MC doesn't ride on this journey alone I like how he cares about his companions and how he uses his past knowledge to factor out the good and the bad about himself and his companions to make this even stronger than their past lives the mc is very thoughtful and smart, This one manhwa is really a satisfying read.
Reply · Aug 22, 2021

alchemyst
I think the thing that really sets this manga apart from others like it, is weakness. It's rare to have a return-to-the-past or reincarnation manga where not only the story but the characters themselves acknowledge their weaknesses. The MC, even though we know he's incredibly capable, knows that in terms of actual raw power, he's on the lower end of the scale, and there's nothing he can do to fundamentally change that. This means that his power comes from knowledge, skill, and experience, which means he can't just do the usual, boring OPMC thing of steamrolling an enemy because "My powerlevel is higher than yours.
Reply · Aug 04, 2021

peekachu
First 200 chapters are 7/10. Meaning good. Last 130 chapters are trash, 2/10 (yes I read ln too). It gives many mysteries and worldbuilding is good in starting. But it solves the mysteries in very poor way, leaving a bad aftertaste. So you could skip it
Reply · Jul 15, 2021

mechanicportal
The story has a few minor detals mising and doesn't do the best job with starting but other that that it's an amazing story and somewhat reminds you of Fairy Tail, Erased, or One Piece
Reply · Jun 03, 2021

coleigh
Warning! Some body horror starting around ch126
Reply · May 20, 2021

tempesthorne99
Review: Wow! 10/10 on the story telling and the plot! The pacing of the story is kind of slow but it was worth it around 80+ and the back to back action is amazing. Mc isn't rly OP but someone who used his mind to circumvent his weakness and made it his most powerful weapon. Mc also uses the power of friendship significantly and is a great commander. This has some major plot twists, which kept me in tenterhooks.
Reply · Apr 30, 2021

klra
This webtoon is about Desir Who travelled back to the past to save the people special to him. Very simple right?
Reply · Dec 27, 2020

killerman08
This webtoon is about Desir Who travelled back to the past to save the people special to him. Very simple right?
Reply · Dec 26, 2020

watthaf
a good manhwa where the mc trime travels back to save his beloved
Reply · Oct 07, 2020

nathandouglasdavis
I would split up the current storyline into three story arcs. The first arc (chs. 1-8) largely serves as an introduction to the world and some key characters. We are introduced to Desir's primary fighting style: using strategy alongside feir ability to quickly analyze and manipulate feir opponents' magic circles. We are also introduced to feir attitude towards other students. Fe cares more about mentoring them toward even greater strength than winning against them. The second arc (chs. 9-38) focuses on the discrimination set up in the Havrion Academy. Talented nobles are sent to the alpha class while commoners and untalented nobles are sent to the beta class, which is given much less attention and help. Desir forms a party which includes a few trusted people in beta class and trains them to be even stronger with the intention of showing that people in beta class can be just as strong as people in alpha class and that they shouldn't be pushed aside. The climax of this story is a tournament between parties. Once again, we see Desir's ability to strategize, but at this point we also see feir ability to bring the most out of feir teammates. The current arc at the time of this review (chs. 39-56+) has its focal point be the first excursion into the Shadow World, which is the phenomenon this manga has set up as the ultimate problem which humanity must somehow overcome. As this is just the first excursion, it doesn't yet have the weight of saving humanity, but it can still be seen as Desir and feir party finally fighting a more serious fight. Unfortunately, in the current arc there are times where the optimal strategy would include involving people other than Desir's party, but instead suboptimal scenarios are pushed probably because it allows the author to keep the story focused on the main characters, but at the expense of writing the best story.
Reply · Mar 27, 2019

nathandouglasdavis
I would split up the current storyline into three story arcs. The first arc (chs. 1-8) largely serves as an introduction to the world and some key characters. We are introduced to Desir's primary fighting style: using strategy alongside feir ability to quickly analyze and manipulate feir opponents' magic circles. We are also introduced to feir attitude towards other students. Fe cares more about mentoring them toward even greater strength than winning against them. The second arc (chs. 9-38) focuses on the discrimination set up in the Havrion Academy. Talented nobles are sent to the alpha class while commoners and untalented nobles are sent to the beta class, which is given much less attention and help. Desir forms a party which includes a few trusted people in beta class and trains them to be even stronger with the intention of showing that people in beta class can be just as strong as people in alpha class and that they shouldn't be pushed aside. The climax of this story is a tournament between parties. Once again, we see Desir's ability to strategize, but at this point we also see feir ability to bring the most out of feir teammates. The current arc at the time of this review (chs. 39-56+) has its focal point be the first excursion into the Shadow World, which is the phenomenon this manga has set up as the ultimate problem which humanity must somehow overcome. As this is just the first excursion, it doesn't yet have the weight of saving humanity, but it can still be seen as Desir and feir party finally fighting a more serious fight. Unfortunately, in the current arc there are times where the optimal strategy would include involving people other than Desir's party, but instead suboptimal scenarios are pushed probably because it allows the author to keep the story focused on the main characters, but at the expense of writing the best story.
Reply · Mar 27, 2019